The Ministry of Finance (MOF) carried out the Budget 2009
Feedback Exercise from 28 October 2008 to 1 May 2009. This
is part of the Ministry’s annual effort to gather views
from the public on their expectations for the Budget and their
response to announcements made in the Budget Statement.
Over 2491 feedback and suggestions were received in the Budget
2009 Feedback Exercise via:
- MOF’s Online Feedback Portal
- Budget dialogue sessions
- E-townhall discussions
- Commentaries in media forums
- MOF’s QSM feedback channel
- SMS feedback channel
There were generally two main areas of feedback from the
public, which the government has taken into account in formulating
various initiatives that were announced in Budget 2009:
For
the government to provide more help to Singaporeans, especially
the lower income group, during this economic downturn
In Budget 2009, the 2009 GST Credits and Senior Citizens'
Bonus were doubled for all Singaporeans, with the elderly
and low-income receiving higher payouts. More targeted measures
such as Workfare Income Supplement (WIS) Special Payments
and additional rebates were also introduced to help elderly
and low-income Singaporeans cope with the recession.
For
the government to provide more help to companies to retain
employees and help employers cope with labour costs
The Government introduced a Jobs Credit Scheme in Budget
2009 to incentivise companies to retain existing workers
and employ new workers where possible. A Special Risk-Sharing
Initiative (SRI) was also introduced to encourage banks
to lend to businesses and help companies cope with costs
during the recession.
MOF would like to thank all those who provided their feedback
and suggestions. The feedback has helped the Ministry to
better understand the views and concerns of Singaporeans
from various walks of life. We look forward to receiving
more views in future feedback exercises.
The main categories of pre-Budget feedback raised by the
public from 28 October 2008 to 1 January 2009 were on:
The following table lists some of the key feedback topics
and MOF’s response:
|
Key Issues Raised |
MOF’s Response |
|
Taxes: Reduction and/or Deferral
|
| Reduce
personal income tax (PIT) / Give PIT rebate |
Singapore’s
personal income tax regime is already one of the most
competitive in the world. Even when compared to Hong
Kong with its low standard PIT rate of 15%, most individuals
remain better off in Singapore as our marginal tax rates
are lower and more progressive. The Government will
continue to monitor the effective tax burden of Singapore
tax residents and ensure that Singapore remains a compelling
place to attract and keep talent, including those at
the top end.
To help Singaporeans cope with the economic downturn,
as announced in Budget 2009, the Government will give
a 20% PIT rebate capped at S$2,000, for income earned
in 2008.
|
| Reduce
corporate income tax (CIT)/Give CIT rebate |
The Government will
continue to ensure a competitive tax regime to reward
the success and enterprise of our companies. In Budget
2007, it cut the headline corporate tax rate from 20%
to 18% and expanded the Partial Tax Exemption regime
to provide a lower effective tax rate for small and
medium enterprises. In Budget 2008, the Government introduced
tax incentives to encourage innovation and entrepreneurship,
as well as a special allowance for fixtures and fittings
which benefit F&B and retail companies in particular.
In Budget 2009, the Government has made a further 1%
cut in CIT from 18% to 17%.
|
Give
property tax rebates
- At least 30% on commercial properties
- Landlords should pass on cost savings to tenants
|
In addition to a
property tax rebate of S$100 announced in the GST Offset
Package to be given in 2009, Budget 2009 announced a
40% property tax rebate for commercial, industrial and
owner-occupied residential properties for 2009. At the
same time, the Government also urged landlords to pass
on the benefits of the rebates to their tenants. |
| Defer income
tax payment for SMEs |
Taxpayers who face
difficulties in the payment of income tax can approach
IRAS to review the payment plans. |
| Allow tax
remission for all foreign-sourced income remitted by Singapore
tax-resident companies |
To enable businesses
to make best use of all their sources of funds to meet
their financing needs in Singapore during this time
of credit tightness, the Government, in Budget 2009,
temporarily expanded the scope of the Foreign-Sourced
Income Exemption scheme to cover all foreign-sourced
income. The Government also temporarily lifted the conditions
currently required for foreign-sourced income to be
exempted from tax when remitted to Singapore. With these
temporary enhancements, businesses will be exempt from
tax on the foreign-sourced income that they remit between
22 January 2009 to 21 January 2010 (both dates inclusive),
provided that the remitted income is earned on or before
21 January 2009. |
|
Job Placement and Re- training
|
| Provide
incentives for companies to retain employees/ Help employers
with labour costs |
As part of Budget
2009, the Government introduced a Jobs Credit Scheme
to encourage our businesses to preserve jobs in the
downturn. Under this scheme, employers will receive
a 12% cash grant on the first $2,500 of each month’s
wages for each employee on their CPF payroll. It provides
a significant incentive for companies to retain existing
workers, and where their business warrants, to employ
new workers. |
- Provide subsidies for Singaporeans who wish to
take up part-time courses
- Help employers offset the costs incurred when employees
go on leave or attend training
- Extend SPUR to more sectors
|
The Government enhanced
the Skills Programme for Upgrading and Resilience (SPUR)
in order to better help Singaporeans upgrade their skills
so that they can stay employed or seek re-employment.
Under SPUR, employers who send workers for training
in certified courses will receive enhanced course fee
subsidies and higher absentee payroll. This helps employers
manage excess manpower and reduce retrenchment.
The following enhancements were made to SPUR to help
PMETs re-train:
- Course fee subsidies for PMET-level courses that
are eligible for SPUR will be increased from 80% to
90%, the same subsidy level as rank-and-file level
courses. This includes all Specialist and Advanced
Diplomas offered by the polytechnics.
- Selected tertiary courses at UniSIM and the three
publicly funded universities will be included under
SPUR.
There are currently more than 1,000 courses offered
under SPUR. These cover a wide range of industries and
sectors for both Rank-and-File and PMETs. Some of the
sectors include: creative, community and social services,
finance, landscape, process manufacturing, tourism and
education services.
WDA will also consider SPUR funding for in-house training
on a case-by-case basis as long as the courses meet
SPUR objectives and enhance the employability of employees.
Employers who are keen to seek SPUR funding for their
in-house courses can approach WDA who will assess their
request.
WDA constantly monitors and reviews the manpower and
skills supply and demand across the different sectors
and if the need arises, WDA will provide more training
opportunities in these growth sectors. |
| Remove
limit on carry back of losses / capital allowances |
For YA 2009 and YA
2010, businesses can now carry-back their qualifying
deductions arising from the current YA up to a limit
of $200,000 to offset their assessable income of the
immediate three preceding YAs. This is an increase from
the previous cap of S$100,000. This will enable SMEs,
especially those affected by the current economic downturn,
to obtain more cash flow relief through a cash refund
of taxes paid in earlier years. |
|
Reducing Business Costs and Facilitating
Loans |
| Give government
guarantee to credit facilities; allow better access to
loans |
To encourage banks
to lend to businesses, the government introduced a Special
Risk-Sharing Initiative (SRI) to share more risk with
banks on their loans and encourage lending to mid-sized
and larger enterprises, as well as trading companies.
More details on the SRI are available on the Singapore
Budget website at
http://www.singaporebudget.gov.sg/key_initiatives/bank_lending.html |
|
Help for Needy Singaporeans
|
Relax
the application of GST
- Exempt GST on basic necessities such as sugar and
rice
- Provide more GST Credits
|
Exempt GST on
necessities
Providing GST exemption for basic necessities is one
way to lower the cost of living for the lower income,
but it is not the most effective way. The bulk of GST
revenue from basic necessities comes from the higher
income and foreigners. Should we exempt these taxes,
we would be giving relief to those who actually do not
need help. Hence, it is far more advisable to keep a
single GST rate on all goods, and use part of the revenue
collected to provide targeted assistance to low-income
families, which is known as the GST Offset Package.
Provide more GST Credits (GSTC)
To help Singaporeans cope with the living costs, the
Government doubled the 2009 GSTC and Senior Citizens’
Bonus for all Singaporeans. |
| Provide
more social transfers to help the poor cope with the financial
crisis |
In addition to doubling
the GST Credits and Senior Citizens’ Bonus, the
Government gave low-income workers a temporary Workfare
Income Supplement (WIS) Special Payment further encourage
them to stay employed. The WIS Special Payment will
provide low-income workers with an additional 50% of
the WIS payments that they will receive over the course
of this year.
The Government also relaxed the WIS Special Payment
work eligibility criteria to enable more low-wage workers,
particularly those with less regular employment, to
benefit.
HDB households will also receive an extra 0.5-1 months’
worth of Service & Conservancy Charges (S&CC)
and an additional month of rental rebates. These are
in addition to the rebates already being given out in
2009 as part of the 2007 GST Offset Package. |
The main categories of comments from the public on Budget
2009, from 22 January 2009 to 1 May 2009 were on:
The following table lists some of the main post-Budget feedback
and MOF’s response:
|
Key Issues Raised |
MOF’s Response |
|
Jobs Credit Scheme |
- Scheme could lend itself to abuse, e.g. employers
could use the cash grants meant to hire local workers,
to employ foreigners instead
|
Employers will only
earn Jobs Credits if they employ local workers. If these
workers are retrenched, the businesses would not benefit
from further Jobs Credits for them.
To prevent abuse of the Jobs Credit scheme in general,
prior to each payout of the Jobs Credit, employers on
the CPF Board’s database will be screened for
unusual contribution adjustments or significant increases
in CPF contributions. For such employers, the Government
will conduct verifications and, if necessary, will withhold
payment to these employers until verifications are completed.
We will also conduct selective audit checks. Should
any abuse be uncovered, employers could be disqualified
from subsequent Jobs Credit payments and face legal
prosecution.
|
|
Special Risk-Sharing Initiative
(SRI)
|
- There is a risk of loan defaults
- Banks may not be as thorough in assessing the credit
worthiness of applicants because the major share of
the risk is borne by the Government.
|
Given the severity
of the credit crunch, the Government needed to do more
to avoid a situation where good and viable companies
are unable to get the funding they need to stay afloat
and grow. The Government has therefore decided to take
on a significant share of the risks of bank lending,
which would inevitably expose the Government to the
risk of loan losses. We have set aside a reasonable
budget to provide for potential loan losses.
Under the SRI, Government takes up to an 80% share
of the risk. We believe that the share of the risk borne
by the banks is sufficient to incentivise the banks
to exercise due diligence in their assessment of loan
applications. In addition, the Government will continue
to have regular exchanges with the banks and monitor
the progress of their lending under the schemes. |
|
Use of Reserves |
| Using the
reserves will set a negative precedent and lead to eventual
depletion of the reserves |
The Government must
only draw on past reserves in exceptional circumstances,
and be able to satisfy the President of why it is critical
to do so. The present situation justifies a draw on
past reserves. The current global financial and economic
crisis is the type of severe contingency that our reserves
have been accumulated for. The two major measures that
will be funded from past reserves (SRI and Jobs Credit)
are of a temporary nature, and will not be built into
on-going government programmes. |
|
Tax Changes: PIT Rebate; CIT Cut
|
| The personal
income tax rebate was well-received, especially by the
middle-income. |
The income tax rebate
is to recognize the contribution of taxpayers, but it
comes with a cap so that more benefits can go towards
the middle-income.
While the lower-income may not stand to benefit from
the tax rebate, they get the highest payout of Growth
Dividends, GST Credits and Workfare Income Supplements,
and receive the most benefits when seen as a percentage
of household income. |
| Reduce CIT
immediately, rather than in YA2010 |
A retrospectively
applied CIT cut is in fact equivalent to a
CIT rebate.
To put things in perspective, we are already providing
substantial benefits to companies this year. The Jobs
Credit alone is equivalent in cost to a 50% CIT rebate.
Unlike the CIT rebate, the Jobs Credit also has a better
chance of preserving jobs for Singaporeans. |
|
Help for Needy Singaporeans
|
| Budget 2009
was too business-oriented |
One of the main aims
of Budget 2009 was to help save jobs for Singaporeans.
For example, the Jobs Credit is a macroeconomic injection
to support the economy, but designed in a way that preserves
the interests of all Singaporean workers – by
supporting their jobs, their wages, and keeping their
full CPF contribution intact.
In addition, Budget 2009 also announced the following
measures to help Singaporeans through these challenging
economic times:
- 20% PIT rebate
- Doubling of 2009 GST Credits and Senior Citizens’
Bonus
- Additional 0.5-1 months’ worth of Service
& Conservancy Charges (S&CC), Utilities-Save
(U-Save) and rental rebates.
- 40% Property Tax Rebates
- 50% WIS Special Payment
- Topped up Comcare funding to S$7 million
- Increased Public Assistance (PA) rate
- Increased funding for Self-Help Groups and Government-funded
Voluntary Welfare Organisations (VWOs)
|
| A GST cut
would have been better than additional GST Credits |
The Government did
consider if a 2% GST would help Singaporeans cope better
during the downturn. However, we decided against this
as an across-the-board GST cut would benefit higher
income households, who are more likely to just save
the money. However, with the GST Credits we are able
to give proportionately more to lower-income households.
In fact, the additional GST Credits given to lower and
middle income households are much higher than what they
would have saved from a 2% GST cut. The 7% GST is also
a valuable source of revenue that allows Government
to fund additional social supports during the crisis.
For instance, the revenue from GST is used to help pay
for programmes for the low-income groups like the Workfare
Income Supplement Scheme. |
|
|